Bellvale Farms Creamery Menu

Introducing Bellvale Farms Creamery: Nestled in the picturesque Warwick, NY, Bellvale Farms Creamery serves as a delightful oasis for ice cream lovers. This veteran-owned gem offers an array of unique flavors, including local favorites like coconut almond chocolate and Great White Way. The ice cream's creamy texture offers a gelato-like experience, carefully crafted to avoid overly sweet notes.

Guests can enjoy their treats in a dog-friendly environment with stunning views of the mountains, particularly mesmerizing at sunset. The creamery is thoughtfully equipped for everyone, featuring wheelchair accessibility, gender-neutral restrooms, and outdoor seating options.

Among the highlights is the exceptional banana split, a once-a-year indulgence according to devoted fans. With friendly staff and quick service, Bellvale Farms Creamery is not just a stop for ice cream—it’s a memorable experience set against a breathtaking backdrop.

Traditional Treats

Cones And Cups

Choose hard or sorbet

$$3.75

Soft Serve

Vanilla, chocolate or twist

$$3.50

Design Your Own Sundae

Size, small or large

Custom Sundaes

Toppings

Whipped Cream

$$0.75

Hot Fudge

$$0.75

Mini MMs

$$0.75

Hot Caramel

$$0.75

Crushed Oreos

$$0.75

Chocolate Syrup

$$0.75

Sour Neon Worms

$$0.75

Peanut Butter Sauce

$$0.75

Mini Gummi Bears

$$0.75

Maple Walnuts

$$0.75

Chopped Peanuts

$$0.75

Peanut Butter Cups

$$0.75

Strawberries

$$0.75

Crushed Pineapple

$$0.75

Mini Reeses Pieces

$$0.75

Mini Swedish Fish

$$0.75

Edible Cookie Dough

$$0.75

Chocolate Covered Marshmallow

$$0.75

Rainbow

$$0.50

Chocolate Sprinkles

$$0.50

Shakes

Any ice cream flavor

$$6.00

Malts

Any ice cream flavor

$$6.00

Floats

Choose your soda and ice cream flavor

$$6.00

Bottled Water

$$1.00

Drinks

Take Home

Quart

$$10.00

Ice Cream Pie

$$25.00

Ice Cream Sandwiches

$$12.00

Ice Cream Cake

See freezer